US Bill Creating the Great Firewall of America

History of Chinese Internet Censorship

In the western world, China has long been infamous for its human rights abuses. Prior to Deng Xiaoping’s re-opening of China to the west in the late 1970’s and early 1980’s, these abuses were largely hidden from the West. With the advent of globalization, the PRC quickly realized the dangers of the internet to China’s fragile societal balance. Beginning in 2005, China began enlisting Western aid in Chinese internet censorship. Western companies like Cisco and Google have long abetted the Chinese government in establishing the so-called Great Firewall of China.

As Western social media developed, the PRC quickly recognized the power of these sites and moved to restrict its citizen’s access to these web sites. While some of these actions may appear to be antitrust behavior to allow local Chinese companies a competitive edge, make no mistake that the primary reason for censorship is the ongoing restriction of information from Chinese citizens. Nonetheless, as the Chinese web has developed, Chinese ‘netizens’ actively find ways around the Great Firewall and discuss social issues around the world. Numerous free tools such as Freegate, Freenet, and Vtunnel provide solutions for Chinese netizens to access the internet in the free world. As Chinese netizens find ways around the firewall, China has continued to step up its policing of the Chinese web.

The Power of Social Media in China

Over the past few years, more and more of China’s human rights abuses have come to light through social media. Ai Weiwei’s recent incarceration and the PRC’s bullying of Ai through gigantic back tax charges has resulted in Ai Weiwei speaking out about his incarceration. Using Google+, Ai was able to communicate methods of donation to help fight back against the $2.4 million back taxes claimed by the Chinese government. According to Chinese law, in order to contest tax charges of this nature, half of the sum must be presented as  collateral. In an awe-inspiring demonstration of the power of Chinese social media, Ai’s supporters around the world have already donated more than $1 million in 2 weeks.

Despite the outpouring of support from the West, Ai Weiwei is quick to criticize Western foreign policy.

“Today, the West feels very shy about human rights and the political situation. They’re in need of money. But every penny they borrowed or made from China has really come as a result of how this nation sacrificed everybody’s rights… With globalization and the Internet, we all know it. Don’t pretend you don’t know it. The Western politicians—shame on them if they say they’re not responsible for this. It’s getting worse, and it will keep getting worse.”

Unfortunately, Ai is more than correct in his assessment. Unfortunately, Western politicians’ short-sightedness extends beyond Chinese foreign policy.

Internet Censorship in the United States

On October 26, 2011, the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) was introduced in the House of Representatives. This bill aims to quell loosely defined “online piracy.” I’d like to compare SOPA to the Chinese web landscape by discussing the two major things that SOPA would do if passed.

1. SOPA allows for suspension of service prior to being found guilty

SOPA does away with the “safe harbors” defined in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). These safe harbors allow some degree of protection for providers like Facebook, Youtube, and Google from liability for copyright infringement. SOPA would hold any site with user-generated content responsible. In Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., it was demonstrated that big media corporations have not considered fair use in the past when issuing takedown notices. In the SOPA world, the alleged rightsholder would be able to force former safe harbors to suspend service prior to being found guilty of infringing on rights. None of the sites that rely on user-generated content would be able to survive in this environment.

While China is not as concerned with IP laws as America is, there are obvious parallels here. The major Chinese Twitter-clone, Sina Weibo, is often forced to censor information without proof of guilt. This frequently involves blocking references to activists like Ai Weiwei who are trying to express free speech. The important point to note here is that in Ai’s case, he has not necessarily been proven to be guilty of anything prior to the repression of his speech. Similarly, whether or not the rightsholders’ property is being infringed upon, the alleged infringer would have to suspend services immediately.

2. SOPA allows the US government to blacklist web sites

Under Section 102 of SOPA, the Attorney General could order American companies from doing business with any alleged infringing web site. While proponents of SOPA have avoided using the term blacklist, make no mistake. SOPA allows the US government to blacklist websites.

If alarm bells aren’t ringing in your head yet, they should be. This is exactly what China has done with the Great Firewall. We have seen many times in China and recently in the Arab Spring that the censorship of internet is a strong component of the suppression of human rights. Recently, the UN has declared internet access a human right. SOPA would be infringing on American human rights in order to protect big media companies from infringement on their content.

Ultimately, SOPA attempts to control the American web space in the same way that the PRC suppresses human rights in China in the name of intellectual property protection. Look, at the end of the day, online piracy is a serious problem. However, SOPA is not the way to deal with it. If the DMCA needs to be revised to adjust to today’s web, then so be it. Let’s be clear here. This is not a slippery slope argument. SOPA puts in provisions that allows the US to control the internet the same way that the PRC does in China.

To  help fight this bill,

Contact your Congressmen


visit and show support for American Censorship Day tomorrow, November 16, 2011.


25 thoughts on “US Bill Creating the Great Firewall of America

  1. Pingback: Great Firewall of the USA |

  2. Pingback: === === popular today

  3. Since congressional insider trading is such a hot topic these days, it would be interesting to see if there’s any angle from that on this issue.

  4. Your article is well written and was a pleasure to read. However I think when you say “While China is not as concerned with IP laws as America is” you are either trying to understate the actual situation or you might not know about the severity of the IP situation in China.

    China has absolutely NO IP protection or copyright laws. It’s Great Firewall of China is entirely a political structure with political reasons for existence and political implications if you circumvent it. The American “Great Firewall”, on the other hand, would be a misguided attempt to protect businesses. I agree with you that in real terms, they might affect end users of web applications in the same ways, but I wanted to make this distinction to your readers.

  5. If you want to take some action, check out They’ve been fighting this bill since the beginning and have made some strides, but more voices could never hurt.

  6. Good article overall, but I have to argue this point:

    “Look, at the end of the day, online piracy is a serious problem.”

    This one leaves a sour taste in my mouth. When Viacom keeps sending DMCA takedown notices and crying that piracy is destroying their profit margins, but they give their CEO a whopping 50 Million dollar raise … Sorry I’m not buying it. They simply want the courts to police their copyrights rather than doing it themselves.

  7. Pingback: Holy #%$@ « MjNet

  8. Pingback: US Bill Creating Great Firewall of America « Netcrema – creme de la social news via digg + delicious + stumpleupon + reddit

  9. Pingback: US Bill Creating the Great Firewall of America | Funri

  10. Pingback: WhatIFindFunny » US Bill Creating the Great Firewall of America

  11. Pingback: US Bill Creating Great Firewall of America | Appenheimer

  12. Pingback: Keep the internet free. « The Zero Hour

  13. Pingback: The Agile Panda: US Bill Creating the Great Firewall of America « Xanthippa's Chamberpot

  14. Pingback: The True Intent of SOPA | the agile panda

  15. Pingback: Links | Hobbits, Home and Abroad

  16. Pingback: Fight SOPA/PIPA | the agile panda

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s